ROTTEN TOMATOES: Geoffrey Macnab

GEOFFREY MACNAB

Agrees with the Tomatometer 67% of the time.

Publications: Guardian [UK], Independent, Sight and Sound

Total Reviews: 41

LISTING OF ALL REVIEWS & ARTICLES

Rating	T-Meter	Title \| Year	Add Date (default)

Fresh 4/5	N/A	Nowhere Boy (2009)	" Nowhere Boy has just about enough music and biographical detail to appeal to Lennon and Beatles fans but it's far more intimate than the typical rock star biopic." — Independent Posted Oct 30, 2009
Fresh 3/5	Fresh 92%	Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009)	" What the film lacks, for all its inventiveness, is the sense of menace and sadism that bristles through Dahl’s best stories." — Independent Posted Oct 23, 2009
Rotten 2/5	Fresh 60%	W. (2008)	" Oliver Stone has a terrible sense of timing. This is a film that has been overtaken by events and already seems out of date." — Independent Posted Nov 7, 2008
Fresh 3/5	Fresh 64%	Quantum of Solace (2008)	" Quantum Of Solace doesn’t seem like a major entry in the Bond canon. Well under two hours long, it’s shorter and more frenetic than most of its predecessors, and an often-jolting experience to watch." — Independent Posted Oct 30, 2008
—	Fresh 100%	A Lion in the House (2006)	Click here to read article — Guardian [UK] Posted Oct 28, 2006
—	Rotten 33%	Wilderness (2007)	Click here to read article — Guardian [UK] Posted Sep 2, 2006
—	Fresh 90%	Sisters in Law (2006)	Click here to read article — Guardian [UK] Posted Aug 12, 2006
Fresh 2/5	Fresh 88%	Who Killed The Electric Car? (2006)	" If Chris Paine's film were half as well designed as General Motors' super-sleek, super-quick EV1 (the electric car whose demise it laments), it would be a film to cherish." — Guardian [UK] Posted Aug 5, 2006
Rotten 1/5	Rotten 13%	Just My Luck (2006)	" The real rot is in the script." — Guardian [UK] Posted Jul 1, 2006
Fresh	Fresh 82%	Chi-hwa-seon (2002)	" A fascinating, consummately crafted and ultimately moving study of a man who conforms surprisingly closely to western archetypes of the artist as rebel and hedonist." — Sight and Sound Posted Jun 3, 2003
—	Rotten 9%	Circus (2000)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 3, 2002
—	Fresh 65%	The Yards (2000)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 13%	Ordinary Decent Criminal (2002)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 12%	Play it to the Bone (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 24%	Simpatico (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 59%	The Luzhin Defence (2001)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Fresh 66%	Me Myself I (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
Fresh	Rotten 48%	The Way of the Gun (2000)	" Brutal scenes are undercut with lyricism and deadpan wit." — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 40%	Snow Falling on Cedars (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 24%	Reindeer Games (2000)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Fresh 79%	Three Seasons (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	N/A	Asterix vs. Caesar (1985)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
—	Rotten 28%	The Story of Us (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Dec 2, 2002
Rotten	Fresh 67%	Amen (2003)	" A handsomely shot but stolid drama." — Sight and Sound Posted Sep 13, 2002
—	Rotten 34%	At First Sight (1998)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 86%	Cookie's Fortune (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 70%	Tango (1998)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Rotten 22%	Just the Ticket (1998)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 83%	Titanic Town (2000)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 93%	West Beirut (1998)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Rotten 49%	Meet Joe Black (1998)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 70%	The Inheritors (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 78%	The Thin Red Line (1998)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 93%	Election (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 88%	The Cup (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
Rotten	Rotten 37%	She's All That (1998)	" Adolescence was never supposed to be this wholesome." — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 69%	Southpaw (2000)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
Fresh	Fresh 97%	Nights of Cabiria (1957)	" Cabiria's story is indeed heartrending, but neither director nor actress allow her time for self-pity." — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
—	Fresh 97%	The Winslow Boy (1999)	Click here to read article — Sight and Sound Posted Mar 5, 2002
Rotten	Rotten 26%	Pearl Harbor (2001)	" Bay fails to bring any insight to his treatment of the event." — Sight and Sound Posted Jul 5, 2001
Fresh	Rotten 50%	Summer of Sam (1999)	" A sprawling, brilliantly acted character study which touches on love, friendship and betrayal, while also managing to recreate the last days of disco without a note of self-parody." — Sight and Sound Posted Apr 17, 2001

Sort by Rating:
Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)
Sort by T-meter:
Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

GEOFFREY MACNAB

LISTING OF ALL REVIEWS & ARTICLES

Sort by Rating:

Sort by T-meter:

Best Reviewed

Best Reviewed

Sponsored Links