Sundance: "Hounddog" Is A Dog; "The Nines" Scores High
Read on for some short reviews of films playing at Sundance: "Hounddog," starring Dakota Fanning, is a cliched stab at Southern Gothic with echoes of Faulkner, and "The Nines," starring Ryan Reynolds, is a trippy, thought-provoking meditation on the nature of creation.
"Hounddog" has been one of the most talked-about films at Sundance, particularly because it has been suggested that it's a movie in which talented Dakota Fanning branches out; however, to quote the titular song, "They said you was high class/ Well, that was just a lie." "Hounddog" is from the overheated and overacted school of Southern drama, filled with stereotypical characters, pseudo-poetic dialogue, and heavy symbolism ("Hounddog"'s biggest deviation from formula is that it features a killer R&B band that plays into the dead of night, presumably on call should 12-year-old girls need help with their personal problems). Fanning stars as Lewellen, a girl obsessed with Elvis who lives with her no-good father (David Morse) and her strict grandmother (Piper Laurie). She plays the character as a cross between an innocent child and a wise strumpet; as a whole, "Hounddog" seems conceived simply to give her a role to flex her pre-teen acting chops.

Robin Wright and Dakota Fanning in "Hounddog"
The film has generated its share of controversy due to a scene in which Fanning's character is raped (it's handled without exploitation). Kiddie porn it isn't. Unfortunately, "Hounddog" isn't much of anything. It doesn't really resonate as a coming-of-age story, a family drama, or an exploration of the 1950s Southern experience, leaving precious little left but the controversy. Ultimately, "Hounddog" is pretty mangy.

Melissa McCarthy and Ryan Reynolds in "The Nines"
"The Nines" is one of those movies that will be the subject of endless interpretation; personally, I just enjoyed the ride. The film is a three-act meditation on reality and the nature of creation with apocalyptic and quasi-religious overtones. In each of its chapters, Ryan Reynolds plays some sort of creator, be it an actor, TV writer, or videogame designer; Hope Davis and Melissa McCarthy each vie for his attention and throw his world into flux in various ways. Like "Mulholland Drive," there's an ominous tone and a sense that everyday events may hint at something harrowing. All of the actors are fine, particularly Reynolds, who shows impressive range throughout. "The Nines" is a solid head trip.
Check out our full Fundance at Sundance coverage!
"Hounddog" has been one of the most talked-about films at Sundance, particularly because it has been suggested that it's a movie in which talented Dakota Fanning branches out; however, to quote the titular song, "They said you was high class/ Well, that was just a lie." "Hounddog" is from the overheated and overacted school of Southern drama, filled with stereotypical characters, pseudo-poetic dialogue, and heavy symbolism ("Hounddog"'s biggest deviation from formula is that it features a killer R&B band that plays into the dead of night, presumably on call should 12-year-old girls need help with their personal problems). Fanning stars as Lewellen, a girl obsessed with Elvis who lives with her no-good father (David Morse) and her strict grandmother (Piper Laurie). She plays the character as a cross between an innocent child and a wise strumpet; as a whole, "Hounddog" seems conceived simply to give her a role to flex her pre-teen acting chops.

Robin Wright and Dakota Fanning in "Hounddog"
The film has generated its share of controversy due to a scene in which Fanning's character is raped (it's handled without exploitation). Kiddie porn it isn't. Unfortunately, "Hounddog" isn't much of anything. It doesn't really resonate as a coming-of-age story, a family drama, or an exploration of the 1950s Southern experience, leaving precious little left but the controversy. Ultimately, "Hounddog" is pretty mangy.

Melissa McCarthy and Ryan Reynolds in "The Nines"
"The Nines" is one of those movies that will be the subject of endless interpretation; personally, I just enjoyed the ride. The film is a three-act meditation on reality and the nature of creation with apocalyptic and quasi-religious overtones. In each of its chapters, Ryan Reynolds plays some sort of creator, be it an actor, TV writer, or videogame designer; Hope Davis and Melissa McCarthy each vie for his attention and throw his world into flux in various ways. Like "Mulholland Drive," there's an ominous tone and a sense that everyday events may hint at something harrowing. All of the actors are fine, particularly Reynolds, who shows impressive range throughout. "The Nines" is a solid head trip.
Check out our full Fundance at Sundance coverage!
Related Items
| Movie: | Hounddog |
| The Nines | |
| Mulholland Dr. | |
| Celeb: | Ryan Reynolds |
| Hope Davis | |
| Elvis Presley | |
| Dakota Fanning | |
| Melissa McCarthy | |
| David Morse | |
| Piper Laurie |
|
Jen Yamato writes: on Jan 23 2007 10:58 PM Go Sookie! (Reply to this) |
|
nogard64 writes: on Jan 23 2007 11:25 PM hey all they have to do is add in 15 minutes of Fanning going into a fantasy world and add some extra violence and gore, extra gun shot wounds to Hounddog and it will get a 97% RT rating! (Reply to this) |
|
rustdog writes: on Jan 24 2007 06:50 AM The fact that Ryan Reynolds is referred to as having range makes me laugh. So are people upset because Dakota Fanning gets raped or because she gets raped in a bad movie? (Reply to this) |
|
dOiNk writes: on Jan 24 2007 08:29 AM In reply to this comment (#853901) [b]?[/b] I'm assuming this is a stab at Pan's Labyrinth? And if it is, how about you see the movie before bashing it? The movie is fantastic. (And if it isn't... then I have no idea what you're talking about) (Reply to this) |
|
nogard64 writes: on Jan 24 2007 08:57 AM In reply to this comment (#853903) nice of you to assume I havent seen it! you know what they say about people who assume!!!!! (Reply to this) |
|
dOiNk writes: on Jan 24 2007 09:27 AM In reply to this comment (#853905) [b]ok then[/b] Well it was either I assumed you never saw the movie and told you to see it first or I assumed you did and called you a retard. (because there is nothing wrong with the movie, it's fantastic) I chose the first option to be nice :) (Reply to this) |
|
unbreakable_samurai writes: on Jan 24 2007 10:11 AM I love a good movie that will take you on a nice trip, so The Nines sounds very interesting to me. Not to supprising that Hounddog isn't that great, I'm sure I'll still see it though. (Reply to this) |
|
h-town24 writes: on Jan 24 2007 12:58 PM As someone you as actually seen "Hounddog", I coundn't disagree with that one review. It's a dark, dark film about child abuse. It was damn impressive!! And as for the "cliched" comment, it's one of the dumber things I've heard about a movie playing here. Now, unbreakable_samurai, after one review you have made up your mind that "hounddog" "isn't that great". Get a mind of your own already. P.S. From what I heard when I was at Sundance, "The Nines" is average at best. (Reply to this) |
|
unbreakable_samurai writes: on Jan 25 2007 11:57 AM In reply to this comment (#853909) I just didn't think Hounddog sounded that great in the first place, that's why I was saying it didn't supprise me that it wasn't that well loved. And not just by one person, last I checked no one has bought it yet, which is never a good sign. I still plan on seeing it though, and I might end up loving it, I don't know. So I have my own damn mind, thank you very much. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |




