Critical Consensus: Critics Pan "Emily Rose," "The Man"
This week at the movies features two of our favorite story elements: demonic possession ("The Exorcism of Emily Rose") and fish-out-of-water-cop-buddy-action stuff ("The Man"). Will the critics see the light, or is it off to the slammer for these two?
Nothing adds spice to a story quite like demonic possession; people are still talking about the time on "Days of Our Lives" when Marlenea was infected by Satan for close to a whole season. So how about a courtroom drama in which the bad guy is the Prince of Darkness himself? Well that's what they tried to do with "The Exorcism of Emily Rose," and the scribes are split as to whether it works. While some have praised the film (which stars Laura Linney and Tom Wilkinson) for its sincere questions about the nature of belief, others say it is unable to sustain a coherent tone and suffers in comparison to the granddaddy of all demonic possession flicks, "The Exorcist." At 48 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Rose" isn't smelling so sweet.
Ever get the idea that some movies are greenlit simply because someone thought, "Dude, that sounds like it might be mildly amusing!" That seems to describe "The Man," a buddy action comedy, starring Samuel L. Jackson and Eugene Levy, that critics say does absolutely nothing to transcend its premise. The plot involves a dental supply salesman (Levy) who wanders into a drug investigation headed by Jackson; as one would expect, Jackson plays a man who does not suffer fools gladly, and Levy plays a loveable fool. At 23 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics say this "Man" is a dog: predictable, uninspired, and utterly average.
Recent Samuel L. Jackson Movies:
------------------------------------------
15% -- XXX: State of the Union (2005)
82% -- Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005)
64% -- Coach Carter (2005)
24% -- In My Country (2005)
97% -- Incredibles (2004)
Nothing adds spice to a story quite like demonic possession; people are still talking about the time on "Days of Our Lives" when Marlenea was infected by Satan for close to a whole season. So how about a courtroom drama in which the bad guy is the Prince of Darkness himself? Well that's what they tried to do with "The Exorcism of Emily Rose," and the scribes are split as to whether it works. While some have praised the film (which stars Laura Linney and Tom Wilkinson) for its sincere questions about the nature of belief, others say it is unable to sustain a coherent tone and suffers in comparison to the granddaddy of all demonic possession flicks, "The Exorcist." At 48 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Rose" isn't smelling so sweet.
Ever get the idea that some movies are greenlit simply because someone thought, "Dude, that sounds like it might be mildly amusing!" That seems to describe "The Man," a buddy action comedy, starring Samuel L. Jackson and Eugene Levy, that critics say does absolutely nothing to transcend its premise. The plot involves a dental supply salesman (Levy) who wanders into a drug investigation headed by Jackson; as one would expect, Jackson plays a man who does not suffer fools gladly, and Levy plays a loveable fool. At 23 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics say this "Man" is a dog: predictable, uninspired, and utterly average.
Recent Samuel L. Jackson Movies:
------------------------------------------
15% -- XXX: State of the Union (2005)
82% -- Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005)
64% -- Coach Carter (2005)
24% -- In My Country (2005)
97% -- Incredibles (2004)
Related Items
|
dave1606 writes: on Sep 08 2005 08:08 PM [b]i don;t think a pan qualifies for emily rose[/b] When the tomatometer is at 51% i really don't think the film qualifies as being panned. 51% sounds like the critics are split about even to me. Some of the reviews seemed quite good for the film so panning is the not the word I would use. I think a panning would be 30% or lower. And yes i know when this article was written it was around 48% but that is still closer to 50. The Man looks awful by the way and I hope it bombs. (Reply to this) |
|
new12play writes: on Sep 08 2005 11:44 PM [b]Jackson the ironic[/b] I think it is somewhat ironic that Samuel Jackson did not want to participate in a movie with 50 Cent (Get Rich or Die Tryin) because he felt like 50 Cent wasn't worth sharing the screen with him. But he finds no fault in starring in flawed and pointless movies like this. I mean come'on Jackson, at least 50 Cent has the intelligence to star in a role that will be directed by a quality director such as Jim Sheridan. Jackson needs to reevaluate his place in Hollywood and realize that he can't just show up and a move make money. I'd put my money that Get Rich will be the movie to see while "The Man" will be shortly forgotten. (Reply to this) |
|
Eros_Amor writes: on Sep 09 2005 08:23 AM i say if its above 50 then it should be entertaining enough to pay 294304934432943934 dollars to see it in theaters.... (Reply to this) |
|
lovelykeira writes: on Sep 09 2005 08:13 PM 50 sucks ass. (Reply to this) |
|
DGates writes: on Sep 09 2005 10:22 PM -- $294304934432943934.00 Is that amount with concessions or without? (Reply to this) |
|
pota1967 writes: on Sep 11 2005 11:26 AM [b]Is it just me?[/b] Or is Eugene Levy just NOT Funny? (Reply to this) |
|
dudemovies writes: on Sep 11 2005 03:00 PM In reply to this comment (#825868) I think he's funny. American Pie movie he was really funny and A Mighty Wind and Best in Show too (Reply to this) |
|
pota1967 writes: on Sep 12 2005 05:27 AM [b]I have just seen[/b] The 40 Year Old Virgin. I was on vacation and feeling whimsical :-) and with this being the Best reviewed movie of the year (maybe it will be as good or better than Theres Something About Mary)--lets take a chance. I was Underwhelmed to say the least. A boring but nice 40 year old and his 3 immature friends. Movies must really suck --or the critics just got tired of panning everything (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |



