Tomato |
The Saddest Music in the World (2004) |
"Here is magic-realism filtered through an oddball sensibility, chilled in the snowdrifts of Winnipeg and bottled in amber-hued frames of celluloid." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic (2005) |
"Here, in her own vehicle, Silverman veers from the faux-naive mockery of minorities into an oncoming collision with white liberal guilt and condescension . . . stand-up [that] makes you sit and think." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
The Savages (2007) |
"Most of all about recovering, about picking yourself up, dusting yourself off, and plugging on. It also just happens to be, in its small, astutely observed, delicately bittersweet way, one of the best films of the year." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Save The Green Planet! (2005) |
"All this melodramatic wackiness might be entertaining B-movie material if it weren’t dragged down by boringly deadly battles between cartoon characters." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Saw (2004) |
"Capped by a final plot twist so insane I almost feel obligated to salute it out of respect for its sheer lunacy." |
Paul Matwychuk |
Splat |
Searching for the Wrong-Eyed Jesus (2005) |
"The stories, usually told by white men, grow banal, and the richness of White's world increasingly seems limited in scope . . . seems racially myopic.
" |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Secret Ballot (2002) |
"Long, still vistas . . . nicely surreal . . . some hard questions about faith and democracy, law and lawlessness, acting for the common good." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato 4/5 |
Secret of Roan Inish (1995) |
No article available. |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Secretary (2002) |
"Secretary isn’t a movie about humiliation or depravity at all; it’s a dizzy fairytale about two people who help each other to stop feeling ashamed of the very things that give them pleasure." |
Paul Matwychuk |
- |
Seven Pounds (2008) |
"SideVue: Where There's A Will . . . Considers Will Smith's career and his formula for Hollywood success." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato 5/5 |
Seven Samurai (1954) |
No article available. |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato 4/5 |
Shallow Grave (1995) |
No article available. |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
She Hate Me (2004) |
"A bizarre stinker . . . it's too bad, for the sake of Lee's career, that this mistake of a movie didn't spontaneously combust on the first reel." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato 3/5 |
Shirley Valentine (1989) |
No article available. |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Shotgun Stories (2007) |
"The end reveals just how poetic, shifting and dazzling Nichols' touch was all along. That's because Shotgun Stories manages to pull away from a hair-trigger resolution with the same inherent right-ness that loaded the story with such tragic force." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Sicko (2007) |
"Moore mostly lets the sufferers speak, their stories revealing the deep, oozing wounds of a broken healthcare system. . . . deliver[s] an adrenal shot, a strangely enervating mix of anger, shame and hope." |
Brian Gibson |
- |
Sideways (2004) |
"Sexuality on Film: 21st Century Men Coming Face To Face With Sexual Mortality" |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
La Sierra (2005) |
"This is no well-meaning, Western-interventionist Born Into Barrios with a sweet ending. . . . La Sierra is devastating, mournful, and unshakeable." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Signs (2002) |
"Shyamalan’s got to be the best Hollywood suspense director since Brian de Palma." |
Josef Braun |
Tomato |
Silent Waters (2004) |
"Swirls amid memory and dreams while reflecting how much is masked by two-faced rhetoric, and how overlooked the victims of patriarchal nationalism and Islamism are." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
The Simpsons Movie (2007) |
"The pace is brisk, the jokes are sharp, and there are sight-gags and zingers that rank up there with some great cartoon moments." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Since Otar Left (2004) |
"Bertuccelli neatly unpacks these three women’s burdened lives and leaves us with a haunting souvenir—the last scene is a shimmering revelation." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
The Singing Revolution (2007) |
"Booster-ish, with only former participants in the struggle and activists interviewed. There's a you-must-feel-good thrust (and an incessant score). Warbles a familiar tune to Estonians, presumably, and doesn't offer enough rich notes for an outsider." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Sir! No Sir! (2006) |
"Not only a fascinating illumination of a blotted-out part of the counter-cultural, popular-protest '60s, but a timely questioning of patriotism and duty in the midst of an increasingly unjustifiable war." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Sisters in Law (1992) |
"Ultimately, it's the rousing, triumphant spirit of [lawyer] Ngassa's and [judge] Ntuba's fierce compassion that makes Sisters in Law a qualified success." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Sketches of Frank Gehry (2006) |
"An allusive and elusive tracing of the man and his work that also offers a rueful rumination on the artistic process." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Solaris (2002) |
"Solaris is what you'd call a "thinking person's sci-fi film," and it has all the strengths and weaknesses that that term implies." |
Paul Matwychuk |
Tomato 3/5 |
Some Mother's Son (1996) |
No article available. |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
The Son's Room (2002) |
"A work of powerful understatement, artfully crafted and subtly acted." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato 3/5 |
A Song for Martin (2002) |
No article available. |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
The Sopranos - Season 6, Part 2 (2007) |
"About Tony's slow imprisonment by his own shallow, grasping selfishness . . . here's the American Dream trying to keep its head down, going about its often dirty business, but always waiting, watching out of the corner of its eye for the blow to come." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Sorority Row (2009) |
"After these Bratz dolls dump the Corpsey One down a mine shaft, the plot follows, dropping us into dark spaces without any emotional gravitas, real scares, smart twists or even B-movie fun." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Spartan (2004) |
"A truly spartan thriller: a clinical, spare exercise by a self-serious plotter that doesn’t leave room for standout sequences, emotional depth or some old-fashioned fun." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Spy Kids 2: Island of Lost Dreams (2002) |
"Just about the surest bet for an all-around good time at the movies this summer." |
Josef Braun |
Splat |
Stage Beauty (2004) |
"Stage Beauty pretends to be a celebration of acting, but in fact it’s saying you’ll be happiest if you go through life playing the most conventional role you can find." |
Paul Matwychuk |
Splat |
Standing in the Shadows of Motown (2002) |
"Standing in the Shadows of Motown takes one of the great unknown stories in music history and translates it to the screen in the blandest way possible." |
Paul Matwychuk |
- |
Star Trek (2009) |
"Projectionist: Reel Life. An essay about film projecting and my experience as a small-town film projectionist, including a near-disastrous screening of Star Trek." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Star Trek: Nemesis (2002) |
"Instead of contriving a climactic hero's death for the beloved-major- character-who-shall- remain-nameless, why not invite some genuine spontaneity into the film by having the evil aliens' laser guns actually hit something for once?" |
Josef Braun |
Tomato |
A State of Mind (2005) |
"Thrusts you into the near-hypnotic mentality of a 1984-ish place. But once you return to [your] society . . . [look again at] those darkly concealing words, "freedom" and "democracy."" |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
State of Play (2009) |
"Both work and play--camerawork and screenplay--elevate Kevin Macdonald's State of Play from the usual conspiracy flick into a smart thriller." |
Brian Gibson |
- |
The Station Agent (2003) |
"For first-time director Tom McCarthy, The Station Agent has been a remarkable ride. 'We’ve had one hell of a reception, you know, far beyond what any of us thought.'" |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
The Station Agent (2003) |
"Observant and whimsical, [McCarthy's film] often has a slyly humourous, lively tone. But this is not a lightweight movie. . . . The Station Agent is an affecting drama." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Stealing Harvard (2002) |
"It isn’t that Stealing Harvard is a horrible movie—if only it were that grand a failure! It’s just that it’s so not-at-all-good. And I expect much more from a talent as outstanding as director Bruce McCulloch." |
Josef Braun |
Splat |
The Stepfather (2009) |
"As characters get startled but you don't and you suspenselessly wait for everyone to figure out what we realized long ago (Mr. Harris kills people, then 105 minutes of your life), you may well wonder about the bloody point of it all." |
Brian Gibson |
Splat |
Strange Culture (2007) |
"A relentless super-self-consciousness leaves no room for subtlety or the viewer's involvement. . . . even the extras are meta and pretentious: the long-running 'interview with the director' is more about her artistic preoccupations and her career arc." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Strangers With Candy (2006) |
"Colbert steals scenes as Chuck Noblet . . . The cracked, sordid style of Strangers with Candy half-bewilders and half-appalls you into laughing." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Stuart Little 2 (2002) |
"A small thing can have large significance: that’s a nice theme for a children’s film to have." |
Paul Matwychuk |
Tomato |
Stuck on You (2003) |
"Stuck on You is pretty much impossible not to like, with its pleasant charm and plenty of laughs supporting a sentimental message.
" |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato |
Surf's Up (2007) |
"Best when it maintains the documentary conceit . . . brilliant tones and shades of lighting . . . the board scenes unfurl in the best surfing movie tradition." |
Brian Gibson |
Tomato 3/5 |
Suspicion (1941) |
No article available. |
Paul Matwychuk |